Message Forums

Gelert or Vango?

Should I notice any difference between the quality of manufacture and fabric materials used betwen these two reputable manufacturers?

We are buying our first family tent so have no experience of either brand, but we have narrowed our choice down to these two options: 

Vango Verona 8 (half price £175 Millets)

Gelert Horizon 8 (£185)

Although the Vango is slightly smaller at 680 x 280 x 195 as opposed to the Gelert 740 x 350 x 225, either should be fine as there's only the 4 of us. We've been touring camping shops for a couple of weekends but not seen a Gelert, where as we have noticed the difference in tent material quality between the top brands and the more budget brands.

I guess what I'm really asking is 'is the Gelert going to be up to the same standard as the Vango, and when I come to sell it will one hold it's value more than the other?'

Thanks in advance for comments.

I had a little Vango, which was a quality tent,  but only used for a couple of weekends.   It was bought for me when I was taking kids without OH.   Nice tent, stood up to very windy weather - but it was only small.  
Sadly we had a bad mouse attack in our camping shed, and this was one of the victims.

Last year I bought (won on Ebay) a Gelert Cadiz 5 (which for some reason I thought was a different, smaller tent), put it up in the garden - nice tent.    Then the gale force winds and rain came.    Well after about a week this poor thing ended up almost flat on its' side (not fully guyed or pegged due to lack of space, and the fact that we were only checking it out when we put it up), and I really thought that I'd lost it.   Well I went out, to dismantle it and take it to the tip.   Well first thing I discovered was that the poles were in tact.   Then I flung the skin over the line - that was fine, just a bit on the muddy side.   Well after it was dried it was put away, and was used successfully on a weekend last year.  

I've owned both Gelerts and (a lot of) Vangos. I'm thinking of one trip we went on when we pitched our brand new Vango Oregon 600 next to our Gelert Cadiz 5+2. (We had friends with us.) Up till then I'd had no issues with the quality of the Gelert but once the two tents were side by side? The Vango had sturdier poles, more and better placed guying points and overall just felt more substantial. I also had to double-guy the Gelert in the end because it wasn't standing up to the wind as well, though this of course could have been due to the slightly different design, despite them having almost identical outside profiles and footprint. (Cadiz 5+2 is a dome + extension, Oregon is pure tunnel.)

I've seen the Horizon up and didn't think it matched the quality of my Oregon, btw. (Cooincidentally it was going to be for my friends that had borrowed the Cadiz.) One thing though...it's got SIG according to the blurb, and I'm not sure if the Verona does. It didn't last year when it was called the (eeerr, can't remember..) and was the Millets/Blacks special then too. This might be important? But otherwise, it boils down to what you prefer. Vango have the edge on Gelert when it comes to ranking tent manufacturers, but Gelert is still pretty good.

Incidentally, any Scout/Guide/Cub etc sons or daughters? You can get 10% off at Millets and Blacks, I think.

Having done lots of reserch since my frst message at the top, I'd advise leaving the Vango Verona 8DLX in the shop. It doesn't have SIG, and the bedrooms slope away sharply compared to the Horizon. Can't comment on the Albany, but we're heading toward the Gelert Horizon 8.