Good camping stores should have self inflating mats on display for people to lay on and test (often on top of stones etc) so if you can get to a store then you can try them out for yourself.
Personally I hate the darn things but that is just my opinion and there are lots of people that love them and find them very comfortable. I think sleeping position plays a part in comfortability too.
From what I have read, Thermarest and Fat airics are possibly the best makes.
Thanks for your replies- I have been reading up about the fat airics and am very tempted, as when there are 4 of us blowing up air beds it becomes a bit tedious.
We have the DreamTime XL's and they are the Dogs Nuts, more of a sleeping system than just a matt, they comprise of a large matt, with foam insert, which is encased in a fleece cover with tough vinyl base, that can be zipped of for cleaning, OK they are expensive, but two fastened together make a superb double bed, best nights kip I have ever had in a tent, anyway I was in COSTCO today, and had a look at thier self inflating matts, at 180cm x 70cm x 7.5cm they are very good value at £17.61 inc VAT, but not in the same ball park as a similiar sized ThermaRest when it comes to quality, the old adage, "you pays your money", comes to mind.
We are SI mat fans, and I sleep on my side a lot and prefer them.
Soemone mentioned thiness and not being so comfortable - there are thicker ones- 7cm or more, but I still prefer a thinner SI mat - I generally use a 3.5 cm one now to an airbed - I've never liked airbeds and I've tried a fair few, uncomfortable and in a tent often cold unless you faff about with extra insulation for them.
I've tried a Drematime, and whilst it was comfortable enough, it certainly wasn't worth the money IMO. and I don't have a problem sleeping on my currrent mat
I have three Thermorests, the thickish "Base Camp," the thin "Prolite" and the green one in the middle. I find the Prolite perfectly adequate and the Base Camp more than adequate, particularly if you wrap it in a cotton sheet so I'd see the "Dreamtime," even at £125.00 as a bit over the top.
A day of all things motorhome and campervan. The show is held both in the main indoor arena and across the grounds. Catering, hot drinks and food options are available. Easy access to the site and free parking included. Win one of five pairs of day tickets